Having display problems? Close this ad.

Barclay slams Hoffman's confidence about GOP result in NY-23

JUDE SEYMOUR
WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 3, 2010
ARTICLE OPTIONS
A A A
print this article
e-mail this article

Assemblyman William A. Barclay, sounding very much like a candidate-in-waiting, slammed Douglas L. Hoffman for comments the Lake Placid accountant made about being assured of the Republican nomination in the 23rd Congressional District.

Mr. Hoffman told the Times Union's Jimmy Vielkind that "there's no question that I'm going to be the Republican and Conservative, on both ballots, in November."

"Doug Hoffman needs to quit acting so arrogant and state clearly and unequivocally whether he will support whichever candidate Republican primary election voters decide they want to be our candidate for Congress against Democrat Bill Owens," said Mr. Barclay, a Pulaski Republican, in a statement. "An election is by definition a question and you don't get the answer until the people step into the privacy of the voting booth and make their determination. We candidates can only ask – but it's the voters who decide.”

Mr. Barclay is one of three potential opponents of Mr. Hoffman in a Republican primary for the 23rd seat.

The assemblyman's press release echoes points made last fall by Dierdre K. Scozzafava, Mr. Hoffman's Republican opponent, namely:

Many residents knew all of this before they cast their vote in last fall's special election. And Mr. Hoffman got 46 percent of the vote on a minor party line. And Ms. Scozzafava got 5.7 percent. So there's an argument that could be made that they really didn't care about any of it.

Mr. Barclay vowed to sign a pledge saying he'd support whatever candidate - Mr. Hoffman, Matthew A. Doheny, Paul A. Maroun - emerged victorious from the primary and challenged Mr. Hoffman to do the same.

“To win back the congressional seat John McHugh use to hold, we Republicans will need to be united,” the assemblyman said. “I am committed to working for a united effort to defeat Owens. Is Doug Hoffman?”

UPDATE: Robert H. Ryan, Mr. Hoffman's spokesman, refused to entertain my question about what his candidate would do if he lost the Republican primary. He said: "“Doug Hoffman has broad based support throughout the district. He proved that last November and it was proven again in a poll released this January. He’s the front-runner in this race and he plans to be the nominee in both the Republican and Conservative parties.”

Mr. Barclay also urged his potential opponent to "urge the Conservative Party to hold off on making a selection until after the Republican primary instead of trying to blackmail Republicans with a threat of either back him or else he will try to cause us to lose to Owens.”

I agree with the assemblyman's central point that Republicans must be united if they stand any chance of unseating Mr. Owens. The GOP has already proved that a three-person race will not produce the result they're looking for.

It will be interesting to see how this all plays out.

Here's the whole release:

BARCLAY CALLS HOFFMAN COMMENTS “ARROGANT”

ASKS WHETHER HOFFMAN WILL SUPPORT WINNER OF REPUBLICAN PRIMARY

PULASKI, NY — BARCLAY FOR CONGRESS EXPLORATORY COMMITTEE, 2 Feb 2010: “Doug Hoffman needs to quit acting so arrogant and state clearly and unequivocally whether he will support whichever candidate Republican primary election voters decide they want to be our candidate for Congress against Democrat Bill Owens.”

That's the reaction of State Assemblyman Will Barclay of Oswego County, one of four possible contenders for the Republican nomination for Congress, to the continuing refusal of Doug Hoffman, last year's losing congressional candidate, to rule out running against the Republican nominee if Republican voters do not select him.

Monday, Albany Times-Union reporter Jimmy Vielkind asked Hoffman if he will support Will Barclay or Matt Doheny or Paul Maroun in the November general election against Owens if one of them is the choice of Republican primary voters.

“That's not even a consideration,” Hoffman answered.

“That's a very arrogant statement,” said Will Barclay. “How dare Doug Hoffman suggest that the will of the people is not even worth considering?”

Hoffman also told the Albany newspaper: “There is no question that I am going to be the Republican and Conservative, on both ballots, in November.”

“An election is by definition a question,” said Barclay, “and you don't get the answer until the people step into the privacy of the voting booth and make their determination. We candidates can only ask – but it's the voters who decide.”

Barclay pointed out that last year Hoffman competed as one of several candidates seeking the nomination for Congress at four open gatherings of Republican committees held in different areas of the district to which hundreds of committee members were invited to attend — and each time committee members were asked to state their preference Hoffman finished last or next to last.

“After first publicly lavishly praising the selection process and then flip-flopping and denouncing it, and after publicly indicating that he would support whoever was nominated and then later denying that was what he meant,” said Barclay, “Hoffman got the Conservative Party nomination and during the fall campaign did things that were embarrassingly inept and foolish.”

“Doug Hoffman publicly admitted days before last fall's election that he knew next to nothing about our local issues and he ducked debating his opponents, one time even fleeing a town a half hour before the scheduled debate,” said Barclay. “That sort of performance by a candidate offends voters and explains why Hoffman lost to Owens and would lose again.”

“I hope and expect that I will emerge as the Republican candidate for Congress,” said Barclay, “but if Republican voters decide that they would rather have Matt Doheny or Doug Hoffman or Paul Maroun as our party's candidate, I will rally behind their choice and volunteer to campaign to help that candidate defeat Democrat Bill Owens.”

“This is a pledge that I will put in writing and I'll send copies of it to the other three prospective candidates, to party leaders and to the news media,” said Barclay, “and I call upon Doug Hoffman and the other contenders to do the same – right now, this week.”

Barclay said he suspects that Matt Doheny and Paul Maroun would agree with him that each of the four should pledge in writing to support whoever wins the primary.

Barclay said putting such a pledge in writing is necessary “to eliminate any confusion and remove any doubt. No wiggle room. No waffling. Just a straight-forward honest answer. That's what Republican voters deserve. Just say Yes. Or just say No. If you can't bring yourself to giving a straight answer to such a simple question, you shouldn't even think of running for Congress.”

“To win back the congressional seat John McHugh use to hold, we Republicans will need to be united,” said Barclay. “I am committed to working for a united effort to defeat Owens. Is Doug Hoffman?”

“If Hoffman is as interested in seeing Owens defeated as he is in promoting himself, he really should urge the Conservative Party to hold off on making a selection until after the Republican primary instead of trying to blackmail Republicans with a threat of either back him or else he will try to cause us to lose to Owens.”

“I will not let Doug Hoffman continue to get away with refusing to say whether he will support the Republican choice against Bill Owens,” said Barclay. “I'll keep asking him this until he gives us a straight answer.”

As for Hoffman's release of a poll he commissioned that shows Hoffman leading Barclay, Doheny and Maroun at this point, Barclay noted that anyone who just came off spending nearly $2 million in a losing campaign would naturally enjoy much higher name recognition compared with others who have never run district-wide.

“Hoffman's poll is a lame bluff, but I guess I don't fault the guy for pretending, said Barclay. “Of course it sure it sure would have been more revealing if he had include in his poll any questions about what people think about his ducking debates and not knowing our local issues. Doug Hoffman knows that the truth is that his poll means about as much as, for example, the early polls that showed Jimmy Carter crushing Ronald Reagan and Michael Dukakis and John Kerry heading into the White House.”

SHOW COMMENTS
PHOTOS
BARCLAY
HOFFMAN
ADVERTISEMENTS
RECENT SPECIAL FEATURES
Showcase of Homes, March 2010
Showcase of Homes, March 2010
Progress 2010
Progress 2010
2010 Bridal Guide
2010 Bridal Guide